CIA argues that UK carbon pricing imposes growing indirect costs on manufacturers through electricity, shipping and waste services, undermining competitiveness. It calls for broader, more generous electricity compensation, funded by government; a review of power-sector carbon pricing; internationally coordinated shipping measures; and waste-sector incentives supporting recycling rather than burdening manufacturers.

The UK Emissions Trading Scheme (UK ETS) is the UK’s main carbon pricing mechanism. It was initially designed to put a financial cost on greenhouse gas emissions from industrial installations and power generators, but has been expanded over time to cover aviation and shipping, with the inclusion of the waste sector only recently delayed. It is well understood that the UK ETS puts a carbon price on direct emissions from UK-based manufacturers. What is less well known is that the application of the carbon price to the power sector, shipping and (in the near future) waste, places additional indirect costs on UK manufacturers.
Electricity prices
The UK ETS drives up UK electricity prices by adding an indirect carbon cost onto electricity consumption. The indirect carbon cost arises because the UK ETS places a direct cost on the burning of fossil fuels in the power sector, i.e. at gas-fired power stations. Unlike manufacturers, which trade on global markets and face competition from overseas, the power sector has a captured market which allows it to pass-through the cost of its emissions to its customers.
The result is that UK manufacturers pay for emissions in the power sector over which they have no control, at an estimated cost to our sector of >£300mn per year, or £21/MWh of electricity used. This is a cost that manufacturers in competing industrial countries do not face and is a part of the reason that the UK has the highest industrial electricity price in the IEA.
In recognition of the impact of this indirect carbon cost, to the competitiveness of UK businesses, the Government established the EII compensation scheme for energy intensive industries. The scheme provides indirect carbon cost compensation to industrial processes in sectors at risk of carbon leakage. Yet very few manufacturers are eligible to claim and compensation is set at only 75% of the pass-through cost to manufacturers.
A similar scenario plays out in the EU owing to the EU ETS, and a comparable compensation scheme supports their energy intensive industries. But last year, in recognition of concerns around industrial competitiveness, the EU adopted an emergency amendment to their scheme, to expand the list of eligible processes to the whole of the chemical sector (part of their European Chemicals Industry Action Plan). At the same time, they increased the subsidy intensity from 75% to 80% for key chemical sector processes.
CIA recommendations
1. The Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade (DBIST) must act now to level the playing field with our EU competitors, by urgently reviewing the subsidy intensity and scope of sectors in the EII compensation scheme.
2. HM Treasury must support DBIST to level the playing field, by making the necessary funds available at the next Spending Review, in 2027.
3. The Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ) should review the need for carbon pricing to drive the power sector transition. Could other interventions achieve the same aim – i.e. to change the merit order in favour of renewables – without adding cost for bill payers?
Shipping prices
The Government brought domestic shipping into the UK ETS from 1 July this year, with a commitment to consider the inclusion of international shipping emissions in the future. As an island nation, the inclusion of international shipping in the scheme would impact the cost of fuel used to import and export goods, with significant implications for chemical sector supply chains which can cross borders many times before final products reach consumers.
The UK Chamber of Shipping warns that without access to alternative shipping fuels – like ammonia, methanol and hydrogen - carbon pricing will only drive up the cost for UK traders, diverting funds from decarbonisation and harming UK competitiveness. As it stands, the scheme applies only to domestic activities, with an estimated compliance cost of up to £170m annually. If extended to international voyages the compliance cost for shipping could be up to £710m.
As currently envisaged the ETS will operate as a carbon tax, not a decarbonisation lever. Pricing emissions before there is access to alternative fuels will not achieve the goal of reducing carbon emissions. Instead, it will encourage the shipping sector to pass through the cost of carbon to their customers. Similar to the electricity market, shippers have a captured market as manufacturers must use ships to receive raw material and send finished product overseas.
Estimates show that annual fuel costs may increase by up to 25-30% for affecting UK shipping. Shipping was introduced earlier to the EU ETS and the European Commission estimates an increase of 1-5% on deep-sea container freight rates for 2024, when only 40% of shipping emissions were covered. The Commission also noted that shipping companies have generally passed these costs on to customers. The impact is expected to increase as the scheme reaches full implementation this year. Similar outcomes can be expected under the UK ETS, pushing up costs for manufacturers, with inflationary and competitiveness impacts for freight and goods.
CIA recommendations
4. DESNZ should not seek to unilaterally implement measures for international voyages (either in port, or from international voyages to/ from the UK) until negotiations on creating a global Net Zero Framework, at the International Maritime Organisation, are concluded.
Waste
In 2024, the Government consulted on bringing waste incineration and energy from waste into the ETS and has since published a partial response to that consultation. More recently, the Government announced that it would delay the inclusion of the waste sector in the UK ETS.
Emissions from the UK’s waste incineration and energy recovery plants comprise around 8MtCO2e each year and, since the closure of the UK’s last coal-fired power station in 2024, the burning of waste to make electricity is now the UK’s most emission-intensive method of generating power. Action is required to mitigate these emissions. Even so, proposals within the Government’s consultation raise concerns for our sector.
The proposal to align the UK ETS with Packaging Extended Producer Responsibility (pEPR), so that the carbon price forms a part of the pEPR cost recovery process, will mean that the carbon price incentive applies to the manufacturing sector, rather than the waste sector. This would add to the policy cost burden of manufacturers who are already paying to meet the requirements of the pEPR, as well as the cost of their own carbon emissions within the UK ETS.
At the same time, it misses an opportunity to create a strong incentive for the waste sector to innovate and invest. Putting a price on the emissions from waste incineration would encourage the waste sector to improve recycling infrastructure and to capture its carbon emissions. Deploying these technologies would help to ‘close the loop’ for carbon used in manufacturing, making recycled carbon available to make circular chemicals and materials.
CIA recommendations
5. DESNZ should avoid linking the carbon price to the pEPR. The carbon price should be applied directly to the waste sector, to encourage competition and investment in advanced waste treatment technologies, that recycle valuable carbon molecules back into the economy.
Reducing the indirect carbon costs to UK industry
The expansion of the UK ETS to include sectors which serve the manufacturing sector has increased the indirect carbon cost to UK manufacturers and will continue to grow if action is not taken. CIA recommends the Government take forward the below actions, to restore competitiveness for UK manufacturers and begin the journey to reindustrialisation.
1. The Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade (DBIST) must act now to level the playing field with our EU competitors, by urgently reviewing the subsidy intensity and scope of sectors eligible for the EII compensation scheme.
2. HM Treasury must support DBIST to level the playing field, by making the necessary funds available at the next Spending Review, in 2027.
3. The Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ) should review the need for carbon pricing to drive the power sector transition. Could other interventions achieve the same aim – i.e. to change the merit order in favour of renewables – without adding cost for bill payers?
4. DESNZ should not seek to unilaterally implement measures for international voyages (either in port, or from international voyages to/ from the UK) until negotiations on creating a global Net Zero Framework, at the International Maritime Organisation, are concluded.
5. DESNZ should reassess its proposal to link the carbon price for the waste sector to the pEPR. Any carbon price facing the waste sector should be applied to waste treatment facilities, encouraging investment in new technologies to recycle raw materials back into the economy.
You can read more about the impact of carbon pricing on our sector here, and the design of a successful carbon trading system here.